DD

Akingu, I really don't know why you bother posting here, as you haven't expressed a single thought yet — you're just belching out your venomous (but harmless) bigotry. Do you think somebody would actually pay any attention to what you have to say? Please …

You may find more compassionate eyeballs in some neo-Nazi rathole. You can't even piss anyone off here — you're that pathetic. I can compare the impact you make to that of a tiny Chihuahua's bark, you miserable worm.

Now that you've cleared your infested throat, crawl back into that hole in the ground from whence you came.

Do tell!

I can surely find plenty of liberals with PhD's at Harvard that will dispute Plaut's accusations.

But I'm not here to defend Sara because I'm well aware that there are just as many nutty professors on the left as well as the right.

As far as jackhampton's advice, he is just sore because he can't dispute any of the rebuttals to the articles at hand due the level of his intellect.

So are you implying that you need a PhD in order to critically analyze the subject at hand or are you just hiding being your fallacy of appeasement?

And to call him an “ideologue and propagandist.” looks like a nasty personal smear. His BBC interview http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/console/p004v8lm (Audio – fast forward to 36mins) makes him sound mild and scholarly. He claims that there is no record, ever, anywhere, of a Roman-time AD70 exile, it's a completely made up story (in the last 200 years by Christians?). He claims that the first Zionists all thought that the peasants of Palestine were the direct descendants of Jews from Jesus's time, and at least one of them wrote of it. Sounds pretty credible to me – I'm not sure that the Khazar thing is quite as well proven, but it's still pretty solid.

http://www.wcfia.harvard.edu/seminars/middle_ea… says:

Lenore G. Martin, Sara Roy & Herbert C. Kelman, Co-Chairs. Jointly sponsored by the Weatherhead Center for International Affairs and the Center for Middle Eastern Studies, Harvard University.

http://www.wcfia.harvard.edu/seminars/middle_east gives the following:

Middle East Seminar … is co-sponsored by the Center for Middle Eastern Studies. Open to the public and off the record, it has become widely known as an arena for the civilized discussion of controversial issues. Professor Herbert Kelman has chaired the seminar since 1978; since 1996, Professor Lenore Martin and Dr. Sara Roy have co-chaired it with him.

Here is my letter to Prof. Kelman:

From: Seva Brodsky
Date: November 19, 2009
To: Herb Kelman
Cc: Steven Plaut, Gerald Steinberg, Robert Spencer, Daniel Pipes
Subject: On the question of your collaboration with Sara Roy

Dear Prof. Kelman,

You may remember me as the person who used to ask all those annoying questions and made comments you didn't like at all during your Middle East seminars, which you have led (and still are conducting, I take it) at Harvard. As you may remember, we once spent a couple hours at a coffee shop at Harvard Square discussing and arguing about all sorts of things of concern to both of us.

I apologize for my absence from your ongoing seminars (which probably does not sadden you in the least) — I wish I could oblige, but I have been living in Israel for the past 2.5 years. However, I still take a keen interest in what is going on in Boston and in the world.

I have just read the following piece about your intrepid perennial sidekick and Middle East seminar associate Sara Roy:

Collaborators in the War Against the Jews: Sara Roy – by Steven Plaut
http://frontpagemag.com/2009/11/18/collaborator…

Setting aside our political, philosophical and ideological differences, I still like you on the personal level — you are an intelligent, educated and kind man. Therefore, I have this question to ask you in all earnestness:

How can you tolerate having a person such as Sara Roy be associated with you? Don't you realize that you are tarnishing your own good name and reputation by this unsavory association? After all, we are known by the company we keep.

With greetings and good wishes from the Promised Land,

Seva Brodsky
Jerusalem

Your ignorance is showing, and by the way, do learn how to spell. Sounds like you're a typical brain dead fascist or muslim. Either way, makes no difference.

You're just plain stupid.

How's Your Uncle Adolf these days? You can always join him, and please take darling Sara with you.